Are Fermented Fish Healthy? Here’s Everything You Need To Know

Exploring the Nutritional Benefits, Risks, and Why Fermented Fish Has Been a Staple for Centuries

As we’ve been expanding our fermented foods recipe collection, the idea of creating a fermented fish recipe made me pause and wonder: Is fermented fish actually good for you? Could it be healthier than regular fish? And what about the risks – should we be concerned about harmful microbes? Most importantly, are the potential benefits worth choosing fermented over fresh fish?

That’s when I decided to take the deep dive. In this article, I looked into the the science and tradition behind fermented fish to answer these questions once and for all. We’ll separate fact from fiction, examine the proven health benefits, and address the real risks – so you can decide whether this ancient preservation method deserves a place in your modern diet or not.

What Is Fermented Fish?

But first things first, What is fermented fish anyway? Fermented fish is exactly what it sounds like – fish that’s been preserved through bacterial fermentation. This includes notorious examples like Swedish surströmming (famous for its powerful smell), Korean jeotgal (often used as a flavoring component), and Japanese shiokara (made from various seafood innards).

People have been fermenting fish for thousands of years, way before refrigerators existed. Ancient civilizations from Scandinavia to Southeast Asia discovered that salt, time, and naturally occurring bacteria could transform fresh fish into something that would last through long winters or dry seasons. Plus, these preserved fish developed unique flavors and textures that became cultural treasures.

But why should you care about this stinky old-school food practice? Well, fermented foods are having a major moment right now, with everyone from health gurus to scientists talking about their benefits for gut health. But while kombucha and kimchi get all the attention, fermented fish might be the “unsung hero” of the fermentation world.

How Fermentation Works?

Fermentation is a biochemical process driven by microorganisms, primarily lactic acid bacteria (LAB), in an oxygen-free (anaerobic) environment. When applied to fish, this ancient method transforms raw ingredients through the interplay of salt, enzymes, and microbial activity.

Salt plays a dual role: it draws moisture out of the fish and creates a selective environment where harmful microbes are suppressed, allowing beneficial bacteria like LAB to thrive. [1]

During fermentation, two key agents drive the breakdown of fish proteins, fats, and carbohydrates:

1. Autolytic enzymes naturally present in the fish (e.g., pepsin), which initiate protein degradation.
2. LAB, which hydrolyze proteins into free amino acids and bioactive peptides, lipids into fatty acids (including omega-3s like EPA and DHA), and carbohydrates into organic acids like lactic acid. This protein breakdown, known as proteolysis (check also: proteolytic enzymes), is similar to the aging process in cheese, where complex molecules are simplified for easier digestion.

Hydrolyze proteins = protein gets converted into amino acids, peptides, and various organic acids.

As LAB metabolize sugars, they produce lactic acid, which lowers the pH of the environment. This acidity further inhibits pathogens and extends preservation.

Regional traditions influence the process: some cultures add carbohydrates (e.g., rice in Korean sikhae) to fuel LAB, while others rely solely on fish and salt.

The fermentation process generates the following key compounds:

• Probiotics: Live LAB that support gut health.
• Bioactive peptides: Linked to improved cardiovascular and immune function.
• Omega-3 fatty acids: Preserved or released for better bioavailability.
• Vitamins: B12, produced by certain bacteria, and other micronutrients.
• Flavor molecules: Aldehydes and esters create the pungent, umami-rich profile characteristic of fermented fish.

The result is a nutrient-dense food with a transformed texture, intense flavor, and enhanced nutritional profile—far removed from its fresh state. Examples like Korean sikhae and Nordic rakfisk highlight how global traditions harness these biochemical principles to create culturally iconic foods. [2]

(Ed. note: While yeast is used in fermenting bread or beer, it’s not typically involved in fish fermentation, where LAB dominate.)

Health Benefits of Fermented Fish

• Gut Health and Probiotics: Fermented fish can provide live cultures of good bacteria. These probiotics may help balance the gut microbiome, which supports digestion, reduces inflammation, and strengthens the immune system. [3]

• High Nutrient Density: The fermentation process helps break down the fish’s proteins, making nutrients easier to absorb. Fermented fish is rich in high-quality protein as well as vitamins and minerals like vitamin B12 (important for nerve health), vitamin D (for bone health), calcium (especially when small fish are eaten with bones), iron, and zinc. [4]

• Omega-3 Fatty Acids for Heart Health: Fatty fish used in fermentation, such as herring, provide omega-3 fatty acids. These healthy fats help reduce inflammation and support cardiovascular well-being by improving blood lipid profiles.

• Bioactive Compounds and Disease Prevention: Fermentation produces bioactive peptides that have antioxidant, antihypertensive, and anti-thrombotic effects. These compounds may help reduce the risk of chronic diseases, like high blood pressure and heart disease. [4]

• Natural Preservation without Additives: Perhaps the most important benefit of consuming fermented fish is that you consume a 100% natural product without any synthetic preservatives. The traditional method of fermenting fish uses salt and naturally occurring bacteria to preserve it. This process prevents the growth of harmful microbes without needing added chemicals, making it a natural way to maintain the food’s nutritional quality.

Potential Risks and Concerns to Consider

• High Sodium Content – Most fermented fish products are salt bombs (up to 30% salt in products like Egyptian feseekh). The preservation process typically requires significant amounts of salt, which can be problematic if you’re watching your blood pressure or have heart concerns. A small serving of some fermented fish can deliver more than half your daily recommended sodium intake. Yikes! [2]

• Histamines and Allergies – During fermentation, bacteria produce histamine (the same compound your body releases during allergic reactions). For most people, this isn’t an issue, but if you’re histamine-sensitive, fermented fish could trigger headaches, skin problems, or digestive upset. [1]

• Contaminants – Not all fermented fish is created equal. Improperly fermented products can harbor harmful bacteria or parasites. For example, Clostridium botulinum or Listeria, arise from non-sterile traditional methods. There’s also the risk of environmental contaminants like mercury or microplastics that might be present in the original fish. [1] [2]

• Strong Flavors and Smells – This might not be a health risk per se, but it’s definitely a practical concern. Have you ever smelled surströmming? Swedish law literally requires you to open the can outdoors because the smell is so intense! Many fermented fish products have bold flavors that can be tough for newcomers to appreciate. [5]

Fermented Fish vs. Other Fermented Foods

How does fermented fish stack up against trendier options like kimchi, kombucha, or kefir?

The main advantage is “nutritional completeness”.

While plant-based fermented foods offer fiber and plant compounds, they lack the complete protein profile and omega-3 fatty acids found in fish. Fermented fish gives you probiotic benefits plus high-quality animal protein in one package.

On the other side, fermented vegetables and dairy typically have much lower sodium content. They’re also generally more approachable for beginners in taste and smell.

How to Safely Include Fermented Fish in Your Diet

If you want to be 100% sure that your fermented fish will not bring and unwanted health problems, follow these simple tips before purchasing or making your own batch.

1. Check the source: Always buy from trusted brands or local producers who follow proper food safety guidelines.
2. Smell matters: Fermented fish has a strong smell, but it shouldn’t smell rotten or moldy. If it does, skip it.
3. Keep it cold: Store it in the fridge to stop harmful bacteria from growing.
4. Watch the salt: Some fermented fish is very salty. If you’re watching your sodium intake, eat smaller portions or rinse it lightly before eating.
5. Start small: If you’re new to it, try a small amount first to see how your body reacts.
6. When in doubt, toss it out: If the texture, color, or smell seems off, don’t risk it.

Bottom Line: Should You Eat Fermented Fish?

After weighing all the evidence, I’d say fermented fish can be a healthy addition to many diets.

If you don’t have sodium restrictions, aren’t histamine-sensitive, and are willing to try new flavors, fermented fish offers unique nutritional benefits that are hard to find in a single food source elsewhere. The combination of probiotics, omega-3s, and highly bioavailable protein makes it a nutritional standout.

However, it’s definitely not for everyone. The strong flavors, high sodium content, and potential for histamine reactions mean it’s not a universal health food recommendation.

The bottom line?

Fermented fish isn’t some magical superfood that everyone must eat, but it’s a nutritionally valuable traditional food that deserves more attention than it gets in many Western diets. If you’re curious, start small and see how your taste buds (and gut) respond.

ℹ️ FoodNourish is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission without any surcharge to you.